PSL Wishlist (updated 04/10/21)
Key:
Gen
Family friendly all-ages business. Can apply to settings and tropes I just want to mess with, or non-shippy character interactions. May overlap with shippy on occasion!
Shippy
Character shipping! Can cover a whole range of things, not all gen. Darker/NSFW stuff will be marked!
Dark
The Messed Up Shit. This can cover angst, violence, or just Uncomfortable Shit.
NSFW
Just NSFW!
Amnesia
Gen / Shippy
⤷ All
Through whatever means (magical, accidental, etc), one character loses all their memories of another character they have a lot of history with. GIVE ME THAT MEMLOSS ANGST. This can also be expanded to a "character loses all their memories past a certain point" scenario, resulting in them losing potentially positive character development. Ryoko & Karin both have canonical excuses for this built into their canons but we can bullshit something for the others too LMAO
Bodyguard Romance
Shippy
⤷ Ryoko, Yuri, Garnet, Sophie, Rin, Stella
One character is in the protection of another character and while they're sticking together through danger, romance blossoms! This can cover a few different types of dynamic (knight/royal, etc) so it doesn't have to strictly be a "bodyguard" scenario. Bonus points for if both the characters are dumb and don't realize they're in love for that sweet sweet not-actually-one-sided-pining angst. Or it could be some sort of forbidden relationship if we want to go THAT kind of route!
Canon Swap/Import
Gen
⤷ A L L
Porting characters into each other's canons! This is just a pretty straightforward AUing situation, but I love working out how each character's particular situation can translate into a totally different canon.
Grouchy Loves Cheery/Softy
Shippy
⤷ Ryoko, Yuri, Honoka, Garnet, Sophie, Stella, Rin, Karin
I'M PUTTING THIS HERE TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE KNOWS HOW IMPORTANT IT IS. I'm EXTREMELY weak for ships where one character is grouchy or otherwise gloomy or closed off and ends up falling head over heels for a character who's energetic and sunshiney or otherwise soft and gentle. it FEEDS me. Ryoko and Karin are the grouches in this scenario, Garnet and Sophie are the softies and Honoka and Stella are made of pure sunshine.
Grouchy/Tsun Guy Loves Soft Girl
Shippy
⤷ Yuri, Garnet, Sophie, Rin
IT'S HERE AGAIN!!! this is basically just an m/f exclusive version of the above because sometimes i need a prideful/grouchy man falling in love like an idiot and begrudgingly chugging I Love My Fucking Wife juice.
Holy Grail War AU/Master & Servant AU
Shippy / Dark
⤷ Yuri, Garnet, Lambda, Akane, Violet
Our characters are involved in a Holy Grail War, in which mages summon the Heroic Spirits of heroes and historical figures from the past to battle over the wish-granting Holy Grail. Once a mage summons a Servant, they become a Master and only the last pair standing can take the Holy Grail! This is basically TAILOR MADE for all of the shippy nonsense here, especially bodyguard romance and injury aftercare. Hell yeah!!!! Mostly for this, I'd be interested in playing around either with translating an existing canon conflict into a Holy Grail War or playing around with our own. I'm most interested in Yuri and Garnet as Masters and Lambda as a Servant, but i'm flexible either way if it seems like it makes the dynamic more fun!
Idols
Gen / Shippy
⤷ A L L
I....... don't have an excuse for this or even a proper summary. I just love idols!!! And I love having CR with idols!!! And I especially love PLAYING idols!!!! So let's do some idol AUs. Let's go MAXIMUM self indulgence.
Injury Aftercare
Gen / Shippy
⤷ Ryoko, Garnet, Sophie, Violet
One character gets hurt (in a fight, an accident, or whatever else) and the other cares for them in the aftermath! It can be something as simple as patching up their wounds, or in the case of more serious injuries, caring for them during their recovery. All girls are good for either role, here!
Isekai/Trapped in Another World
Gen / Shippy
⤷ A L L
Our characters find themselves taken from their own worlds and dropped in a new one together! This can either be a general jamjar setting like a regular DWRP game, or we can go Full Isekai Genre with it and have them summoned as heroes fighting to save the world!!!! or something. Either way, they go on adventures together, get into trouble and grow closer. Might get shippy, or might not!
MAKING OCs!!!!
Gen / Shippy
⤷
I'VE ENTRAPPED YOU!!!! but no this is basically the "if anything here pings you but you don't have the right characters for it, we can brainstorm an original scenario and some OCs to make it happen" entry. BECAUSE I CLEARLY DON'T PLAY ENOUGH OCs.
Magical Girls
Gen / Shippy
⤷ A L L
I can't believe it took me so long to add this. I LOVE MAGICAL GIRLS!! This can either be stuff like AUs where the canon story is adapted to be a magical girl story or just the charactera randomly becoming magical girls one day?? THE POSSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS. I've put ALL on here bc i'm so weak for magical girls but Magical Girl Ryoko is the one who lives the one who lives rent free in my head.
Murdergame
Shippy / Dark
⤷ A L L
I JUST... LOVE... MURDERGAME SCENARIOS.... SO MUCH!!!! This can overlap with a lot of other stuff here like amnesia or injurt aftercare or whatever! There's lots of things to play around with here. Mostly I'm interested in playing out stuff like murders, investigations, trials and aftermaths. The fun shit. Shippy options are always available of course so we can go the super angsty route and MAKE THEM KILL EACH OTHER.
Post-Apocalypse Survival
Gen / Shippy / Dark
⤷ Ryoko, Garnet, Lambda, Sophie, Akane, Violet, Karin
Through whatever means (zombies, war, whatever) the world has come to an end, society has collapsed and our characters have to survive together! This can be as simple as the day-to-day mundane aspects of their life and how their survive, or we can get really into the details and explore what happened, how they're surviving and what (if any) danger they have to evade. And also, we can have the situation push them closer together and have lots of delicious angst on THAT front.
Raising a Family
Gen / Shippy
⤷ Ryoko, Honoka, Garnet, Sophie, Rin, Violet, Karin
Y'ALL..... YOU KNOW I GO FERAL FOR THIS FAMILY SHIT!!!! This can be shippy, with characters raising a child together (either their own or adopted, or otherwise Found) OR it can be cute found family interactions! Whatever floats your boat! We can also twist it a bit and have one character be the kid being raised. GIMME THAT CUTE FAMILY SHIT.
Revolutionary Girl Utena AU/"Be My Revolution"
Shippy / Dark / NSFW
⤷ Yuri, Garnet, Lambda, Akane, Violet
A PSL/AU/whatever taking cues from Revolutionary Girl Utena! ADMITTEDLY IT'S VERY DIET UTENA and based primarily on the Be My Revolution meme that I am OBSESSED with. Characters are paired together as Groom and Bride and have to fight other Grooms, while also having a whole bunch of interpersonal drama. As the meme itself puts it: One part strength through sex, one part soulmates meme, one part sentinel/guides meme, add some fighting couples and a whole lot of (prettily packaged) mindfuck... I'm happy to completely yeet the sexual aspect of it I just think this premise is cool!!!
Reunions
Gen / Shippy
⤷ A L L
A scenario where the characters have been separated for a long-ass time (either through death, one character going missing, etc) and suddenly find each other again! They have to catch up with one another and sort of work out what their place in each other's lives will be. Pretty much all the girls here are good for either role, but Rin especially has a good hook for this given that she was stuck in her little spaceship for like seven years.
Strangers to Family
Gen
⤷ A L L
Yes this is ALSO going on here with the other family prompt!! Get off my back!!! This one is more specifically geared to characters meeting as strangers (so this can overlap really well with anything else on this list) and eventually becoming family! YOU KNOW WE WANT THAT FOUND FAMILY SHIT
Villain x Hero
Shippy / Dark
⤷ Ryoko, Yuri, Garnet, Lambda, Akane
hoots and hollers. I Would Just Like It If A Villainous Type Fell In Love With A Pure Hearted Girl. this can be your typical enemies to lovers dynamic with the villain changing sides because of love OR!!! (and this is where it gets dark) it can be more of a corruption thing where the hero decides to side with the villain. Garnet is firmly in the hero role here, Ryoko and Yuri can be either heroes or villains and Lambda and Akane are firmly in the villain role.
Yandere
Shippy / Dark / NSFW
⤷ Yuri, Garnet, Lambda, Akane
THERE'S A BUNCH OF YANDERE GIRLS ON THIS LIST.... YOU HAD TO KNOW THIS WAS COMING!!! This is mostly just here as a catch-all for any sort of horrible nonsense that involves any of the characters involved in a ship deciding to go a bit feral and yandere for their love interest. BE SUPER WARNED that this could get dark and heavy fast! It'll probably involve captivity, violence, manipulation, Some Sort Of Fucked Up Dubious Consent, and just General Unpleasantness. Lambda and Akane are firmly in the yandere category for this, Yuri can be either the yandere or the love interest and Garnet is firmly in the Nice Girl Love Interest Who Doesn't Deserve This category.

no subject
[Hopefully they or someone else will find something to make it make sense?]
[That looks to be it on the hands front, though. Might have to search the body a little more.]
He didn't seem like he was much of a fighter, either...
no subject
[ Talking to Pyrrha's helping her not throw up and faint while she examines the body, at least. Fun stuff! What else is there for her to make note of? ]
no subject
It wouldn't have been hard. He didn't strike me as very violent at all, but if he were going out at night and trying to be cautious-
[His attempt at safety might have been his undoing, the mastermind probably loved that kind of sick irony.]
no subject
How sad... he was hoping to defend himself and it was turned against him...
[ Actually. Hold on a second. ]
But isn't that strange? Why would he be out so late at night?
no subject
That's right, he wouldn't have just been patrolling. Someone must have called him out, but- who would he trust that much?
no subject
... It's awful to say it, but with things as they are now... I don't think it would be anyone, would it?
[ She looks visibly upset just saying it. ]
At least not on a Thursday night, anyway.
no subject
He seemed so cautious. You don't think-
[Saxon had been a bit odd at times, maybe, but there had never been anything to make Pyrrha think he was capable of murder.]
This can't be another case of self-defense.
[Please.]
no subject
I really, really, don't want to think like that, but... well, I really don't like any of our other options, either.
[ She sighs. ]
Maybe... we should look over the other evidence before we start trying to come up with a theory? We might see something that proves or disproves what we come up with.
no subject
[Executing anyone is terrible, but when it's someone who was just defending themselves, or in the wrong place at the wrong time-]
Are you okay to keep looking? I know this is hard.
[It's bad enough helping, nevermind being the one to actually search the bodies.]
no subject
[ She was going to say "I'm fine" but that's not... uh, strictly true. So she hastily revises it. ]
I can do it. It'd be worse knowing anybody else had to, because I felt like I couldn't.
[ And with that, back to body touching. Anything else fucky here? ]
no subject
Just don't be afraid to ask for help. We're all a team here, right? And- I'm here for you. Don't forget that.
[Looks like nothing else is fucky about the body, except the implications you've already noodled out. Guess you'll have to check the rest of the room. Won't that be fun?]
no subject
[ She takes a deep, steadying breath and though she would rather be doing literally anything else right now, she sets to investigating around the body, too. Surely there has to be something that would explain what happened here? ]